diff --git a/packages/o/objfw/xmake.lua b/packages/o/objfw/xmake.lua
index 7ed408d0c90..206eb43697c 100644
--- a/packages/o/objfw/xmake.lua
+++ b/packages/o/objfw/xmake.lua
@@ -75,21 +75,18 @@ package("objfw")
     add_configs("arc", { description = "Enable Automatic Reference Counting (ARC) support.", default = true, type = "boolean" })
 
     on_load(function (package)
-        if package:is_plat("macosx") and package:version() and package:version():gt("1.4.4") and package:config("tls") == "securetransport" then
-            package:config_set("tls", "openssl")
-        end
         local tls = package:config("tls")
         if type(tls) == "boolean" then
             if tls then
                 if package:is_plat("macosx") then
                     package:add("frameworks", "Security")
                 else
-                    package:add("deps", "openssl")
+                    package:add("deps", "openssl3")
                 end
             end
         elseif tls then
             if tls == "openssl" then
-                package:add("deps", "openssl")
+                package:add("deps", "openssl3")
             elseif tls == "securetransport" then
                 package:add("frameworks", "Security")
             elseif tls == "gnutls" then
@@ -134,7 +131,7 @@ package("objfw")
 
         -- SecureTransport must be handled by system so we don't worry about providing CFLAGS and LDFLAGS,
         -- but for OpenSSL and GnuTLS we need to provide the paths
-        local ssl = package:dep("openssl") or package:dep("gnutls")
+        local ssl = package:dep("openssl3") or package:dep("gnutls") or package:dep("openssl")
         local is_gnu = ssl and ssl:name() == "gnutls"
         if ssl then
             import("lib.detect.find_library")
@@ -150,8 +147,6 @@ package("objfw")
             if libssl then
                 table.insert(configs, "CPPFLAGS=-I" .. ssl_incdir)
                 table.insert(configs, "LDFLAGS=-L" .. libssl.linkdir)
-            else
-                print("No SSL library found, using system default")
             end
         end