diff --git a/src/sinon/mock.js b/src/sinon/mock.js
index 9f36b141b..2e34bae50 100644
--- a/src/sinon/mock.js
+++ b/src/sinon/mock.js
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ import wrapMethod from "./util/core/wrap-method.js";
 
 const { prototypes } = commons;
 const { deepEqual } = samsam;
-const { concat, filter, forEach, every, join, push, slice, unshift } =
+const { concat, filter, forEach, every, join, push, reduce, slice, unshift } =
     prototypes.array;
 
 /**
@@ -125,6 +125,13 @@ extend(mock, {
                 ? this.expectations[method]
                 : [];
         const currentArgs = args || [];
+        const callIndex = reduce(
+            expectations,
+            function (count, expectation) {
+                return count + expectation.callCount;
+            },
+            0,
+        );
         let available;
 
         const expectationsWithMatchingArgs = filter(
@@ -151,7 +158,12 @@ extend(mock, {
         );
 
         if (expectationsToApply.length > 0) {
-            return expectationsToApply[0].apply(thisValue, args);
+            return invokeExpectation(
+                expectationsToApply[0],
+                thisValue,
+                args,
+                callIndex,
+            );
         }
 
         const messages = [];
@@ -166,7 +178,7 @@ extend(mock, {
         });
 
         if (available && exhausted === 0) {
-            return available.apply(thisValue, args);
+            return invokeExpectation(available, thisValue, args, callIndex);
         }
 
         forEach(expectations, function (expectation) {
@@ -202,3 +214,12 @@ extend(mock, {
         mockExpectation.fail(join(messages, "\n"));
     },
 });
+
+function invokeExpectation(expectation, thisValue, args, callIndex) {
+    expectation.behaviorCallIndex = callIndex;
+    try {
+        return expectation.apply(thisValue, args);
+    } finally {
+        delete expectation.behaviorCallIndex;
+    }
+}
diff --git a/src/sinon/stub.js b/src/sinon/stub.js
index 4e84ed237..c3e78bcc7 100644
--- a/src/sinon/stub.js
+++ b/src/sinon/stub.js
@@ -173,7 +173,11 @@ function getDefaultBehavior(stubInstance) {
 }
 
 function getCurrentBehavior(stubInstance) {
-    const currentBehavior = stubInstance.behaviors[stubInstance.callCount - 1];
+    const currentCall =
+        typeof stubInstance.behaviorCallIndex === "number"
+            ? stubInstance.behaviorCallIndex
+            : stubInstance.callCount - 1;
+    const currentBehavior = stubInstance.behaviors[currentCall];
     return currentBehavior && currentBehavior.isPresent()
         ? currentBehavior
         : getDefaultBehavior(stubInstance);
diff --git a/test/src/mock-test.js b/test/src/mock-test.js
index 542eb58d8..60cd7626d 100644
--- a/test/src/mock-test.js
+++ b/test/src/mock-test.js
@@ -1234,6 +1234,51 @@ describe("sinonMock", function () {
                 object.method(42);
             });
         });
+
+        it("returns callsFake values from ordered matching expectations", function () {
+            const object = {
+                accumulator: [],
+                accumulate: function (thing) {
+                    this.accumulator.push(thing);
+                    return `added ${thing}`;
+                },
+            };
+            const mock = sinonMock(object);
+
+            mock.expects("accumulate")
+                .withArgs("first thing")
+                .onCall(0)
+                .callsFake(function (thing) {
+                    return `mock-added ${thing}`;
+                });
+            mock.expects("accumulate")
+                .withArgs("second thing")
+                .onCall(1)
+                .callsFake(function (thing) {
+                    return `mock-added ${thing}`;
+                });
+            mock.expects("accumulate")
+                .withArgs("third thing")
+                .onCall(2)
+                .callsFake(function (thing) {
+                    return `mock-added ${thing}`;
+                });
+
+            assert.equals(object.accumulator.length, 0);
+            assert.equals(
+                object.accumulate("first thing"),
+                "mock-added first thing",
+            );
+            assert.equals(
+                object.accumulate("second thing"),
+                "mock-added second thing",
+            );
+            assert.equals(
+                object.accumulate("third thing"),
+                "mock-added third thing",
+            );
+            mock.verify();
+        });
     });
 
     describe("mock function", function () {