From da3c99b559bae279441a99294f622fa741e4aa58 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Hans5958 Date: Fri, 1 May 2026 18:46:08 +0700 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] Clarify "Specify original" and adjacent OoS rule - Strictly refer OoS on the OoS rule to avoid duplicate mentions - Add mention on cover unifier as first priority - Put external link in higher priority following the "Specify original" priority - Adjust for clearer language - Add excerpt and related rules --- src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx | 24 +++++++++++++---- .../rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx | 27 ++++++++++++++++--- 2 files changed, 43 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx b/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx index b909695..375ecc1 100644 --- a/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx +++ b/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx @@ -17,11 +17,25 @@ status: Active rule_context: mikumod_support: "Planned" relevant_tag_id: 4631 +excerpt: > + For derived songs, refer the original by... + - adding the song entry on the "Original version" field + - adding the UtaiteDB/TouhouDB entry as an external link + - following [the "Specify out-of-scope original" rule](/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original) + - adding the "[original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631)" tag --- -Derived songs should either: +import RuleEmbed from "@/components/markdown/RuleEmbed.astro"; -- Specify the `Original version` field. -- Refer as an external link to the original entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/), if applicable. This will display it as the "Original version" along with automatic metadata. -- Include the [human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193/human-original) or [instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491/instrumental-original) tag. -- Include the [original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631) tag. +Derived songs should have a reference to the original song by doing the following, in priority from top to bottom: + +1. Specify the "Original version" field. +2. Add the original entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/) as an external link. This will display it as the "Original version" along with automatic metadata. +3. If it is out-of-scope of the database, follow [the "Specify out-of-scope original" rule](/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original). +4. If it is unknown, add the [original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631) tag. + +This includes if the original song is out-of-scope. Refer to [the "Specify out-of-scope original" rule] for more information. + +## Related rules + + diff --git a/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx b/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx index 51f7825..ddc3b8c 100644 --- a/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx +++ b/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx @@ -17,9 +17,30 @@ status: Active rule_context: mikumod_support: "Planned" relevant_tag_id: 3282 +excerpt: > + For derived songs with out-of-scope original, add the respective tags ([human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193)/[instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491)) and refer the original by... + - adding [the cover unifier](/rules/cover-unifiers) on the "Original version" field + - adding the UtaiteDB/TouhouDB entry as an external link + - mentioning it on the description --- -If the [human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193) tag or the [instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491/instrumental-original) tag is included, the original version should be: +import RuleEmbed from "@/components/markdown/RuleEmbed.astro"; +import { BoxGroup } from "@/components/Box.tsx"; -- specified in the song description AND/OR -- included as an external link (required for UtaiteDB originals). +If the original version of a vocal synth song is out of scope of the database, tag it with the following tags for songs with out-of-scope originals: + +- [human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193) +- [instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491) + +The original song should still be referred by doing the following, in priority from top to bottom: + +1. If [the cover unifier exists](/rules/cover-unifiers), specify it on the "Original version" field. +2. Add the original entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/) as an external link. +3. Mention it in the entry description. At least [the artist should be included](/rules/out-of-scope-artist-crediting-for-derived-songs). If the song title is different to the original, also include the original title. + +## Related rules + + + + + From 158fa549aac0690e5b0ba28b1d105836136068ea Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Hans5958 Date: Wed, 6 May 2026 16:39:55 +0700 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] Clarify "Specify original" and adjacent OoS rule 2 - Clarify by doing one of the following, not all of it - Use "attribute" instead of "refer"; "referred to by" sounds weird - Remove duplicate sentence regarding OoS on "Specify original" - Little bit of linguistic adjustments --- src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx | 22 +++++++++---------- .../rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx | 14 ++++++------ 2 files changed, 17 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx b/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx index 375ecc1..7f35b05 100644 --- a/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx +++ b/src/content/rules/specify-original.mdx @@ -18,23 +18,21 @@ rule_context: mikumod_support: "Planned" relevant_tag_id: 4631 excerpt: > - For derived songs, refer the original by... - - adding the song entry on the "Original version" field - - adding the UtaiteDB/TouhouDB entry as an external link - - following [the "Specify out-of-scope original" rule](/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original) - - adding the "[original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631)" tag + For derived songs, attribute the original by one of the following: + - Adding the original entry on the "Original version" field + - Adding the UtaiteDB/TouhouDB entry as an external link + - Following the "[Specify out-of-scope original](/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original)" rule + - Adding the "[original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631)" tag --- import RuleEmbed from "@/components/markdown/RuleEmbed.astro"; -Derived songs should have a reference to the original song by doing the following, in priority from top to bottom: +The original song of a derivative should be attributed by doing one of the following, in priority from top to bottom: -1. Specify the "Original version" field. -2. Add the original entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/) as an external link. This will display it as the "Original version" along with automatic metadata. -3. If it is out-of-scope of the database, follow [the "Specify out-of-scope original" rule](/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original). -4. If it is unknown, add the [original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631) tag. - -This includes if the original song is out-of-scope. Refer to [the "Specify out-of-scope original" rule] for more information. +1. Specify the entry in the "Original version" field. +2. Add the entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/) as an external link. This will display it as the "Original version" along with automatic metadata. +3. If it is out-of-scope of the database, follow the "[Specify out-of-scope original](/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original)" rule. +4. If it is unknown, add the "[original version unknown](https://vocadb.net/T/4631)" tag. ## Related rules diff --git a/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx b/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx index ddc3b8c..7b189aa 100644 --- a/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx +++ b/src/content/rules/specify-out-of-scope-original.mdx @@ -18,10 +18,10 @@ rule_context: mikumod_support: "Planned" relevant_tag_id: 3282 excerpt: > - For derived songs with out-of-scope original, add the respective tags ([human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193)/[instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491)) and refer the original by... - - adding [the cover unifier](/rules/cover-unifiers) on the "Original version" field - - adding the UtaiteDB/TouhouDB entry as an external link - - mentioning it on the description + For derived songs with out-of-scope original, add the relevant tags ([human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193)/[instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491)) and attribute the original by one of the following: + - Adding the [cover unifier](/rules/cover-unifiers) on the "Original version" field + - Adding the UtaiteDB/TouhouDB entry as an external link + - Mentioning it on the description --- import RuleEmbed from "@/components/markdown/RuleEmbed.astro"; @@ -32,10 +32,10 @@ If the original version of a vocal synth song is out of scope of the database, t - [human original](https://vocadb.net/T/3193) - [instrumental original](https://vocadb.net/T/12491) -The original song should still be referred by doing the following, in priority from top to bottom: +The original song should still be attributed by doing one of the following, in priority from top to bottom: -1. If [the cover unifier exists](/rules/cover-unifiers), specify it on the "Original version" field. -2. Add the original entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/) as an external link. +1. If the [cover unifier](/rules/cover-unifiers) exists, specify it in the "Original version" field. +2. Add the entry on [UtaiteDB](https://utaitedb.net/S/) or [TouhouDB](https://touhoudb.com/) as an external link. 3. Mention it in the entry description. At least [the artist should be included](/rules/out-of-scope-artist-crediting-for-derived-songs). If the song title is different to the original, also include the original title. ## Related rules